Cookies Policy
The website need some cookies and similar means to function. If you permit us, we will use those means to collect data on your visits for aggregated statistics to improve our service. Find out More
Accept Reject
  • Menu
Publications

Publications by CTM

2024

Combining Gaia and GRAVITY: Characterising five new directly detected substellar companions

Authors
Winterhalder, TO; Lacour, S; Mérand, A; Kammerer, J; Maire, A; Stolker, T; Pourré, N; Babusiaux, C; Glindemann, A; Abuter, R; Amorim, A; Asensio Torres, R; Balmer, WO; Benisty, M; Berger, J; Beust, H; Blunt, S; Boccaletti, A; Bonnefoy, M; Bonnet, H; Bordoni, MS; Bourdarot, G; Brandner, W; Cantalloube, F; Caselli, P; Charnay, B; Chauvin, G; Chavez, A; Choquet, E; Christiaens, V; Clénet, Y; du Foresto, V; Cridland, A; Davies, R; Dembet, R; Dexter, J; Drescher, A; Duvert, G; Eckart, A; Eisenhauer, F; Schreiber, NM; Garcia, P; Lopez, R; Gardner, T; Gendron, E; Genzel, R; Gillessen, S; Girard, JH; Grant, S; Haubois, X; Heißel, G; Henning, TH; Hinkley, S; Hippler, S; Houllé, M; Hubert, Z; Jocou, L; Keppler, M; Kervella, P; Kreidberg, L; Kurtovic, NT; Lagrange, A; Lapeyrère, V; Le Bouquin, J; Lutz, D; Mang, F; Marleau, G; Mollière, P; Monnier, JD; Mordasini, C; Mouillet, D; Nasedkin, E; Nowak, M; Ott, T; Otten, GPPL; Paladini, C; Paumard, T; Perraut, K; Perrin, G; Pfuhl, O; Pueyo, L; Ribeiro, DC; Rickman, E; Rustamkulov, Z; Shangguan, J; Shimizu, T; Sing, D; Stadler, J; Straub, O; Straubmeier, C; Sturm, E; Tacconi, LJ; van Dishoeck, EF; Vigan, A; Vincent, F; von Fellenberg, SD; Wang, JJ; Widmann, F; Woillez, J; Yazici, S;

Publication
Astronomy and Astrophysics

Abstract
Precise mass constraints are vital for the characterisation of brown dwarfs and exoplanets. Here we present how the combination of data obtained by Gaia and GRAVITY can help enlarge the sample of substellar companions with measured dynamical masses. We show how the Non-Single-Star (NSS) two-body orbit catalogue contained in Gaia DR3 can be used to inform high-angular-resolution follow-up observations with GRAVITY. Applying the method presented in this work to eight Gaia candidate systems, we detect all eight predicted companions, seven of which were previously unknown and five are of a substellar nature. Among the sample is Gaia DR3 2728129004119806464 B, which – detected at an angular separation of (34.01 ± 0.15) mas from the host – is the closest substellar companion ever imaged. In combination with the system’s distance and the orbital elements, this translates to a semi-major axis of (0.938 ± 0.023) AU. WT 766 B, detected at a greater angular separation, was confirmed to be on an orbit exhibiting an even smaller semi-major axis of (0.676 ± 0.008) AU. The GRAVITY data were then used to break the host-companion mass degeneracy inherent to the Gaia NSS orbit solutions as well as to constrain the orbital solutions of the respective target systems. Knowledge of the companion masses enabled us to further characterise them in terms of their ages, effective temperatures, and radii via the application of evolutionary models. The inferred ages exhibit a distinct bias towards values younger than what is to be expected based on the literature. The results serve as an independent validation of the orbital solutions published in the NSS two-body orbit catalogue and show that the combination of astrometric survey missions and high-angular-resolution direct imaging holds great promise for efficiently increasing the sample of directly imaged companions in the future, especially in the light of Gaia’s upcoming DR4 and the advent of GRAVITY+. © The Authors 2024.

2024

Four-of-a-kind? Comprehensive atmospheric characterisation of the HR 8799 planets with VLTI/GRAVITY

Authors
Nasedkin, E; Mollière, P; Lacour, S; Nowak, M; Kreidberg, L; Stolker, T; Wang, JJ; Balmer, WO; Kammerer, J; Shangguan, J; Abuter, R; Amorim, A; Asensio-Torres, R; Benisty, M; Berger, JP; Beust, H; Blunt, S; Boccaletti, A; Bonnefoy, M; Bonnet, H; Bordoni, MS; Bourdarot, G; Brandner, W; Cantalloube, F; Caselli, P; Charnay, B; Chauvin, G; Chavez, A; Choquet, E; Christiaens, V; Clenet, Y; du Foresto, VC; Cridland, A; Davies, R; Dembet, R; Dexter, J; Drescher, A; Duvert, G; Eckart, A; Eisenhauer, F; Schreiber, NMF; Garcia, P; Lopez, RG; Gendron, E; Genzel, R; Gillessen, S; Girard, JH; Grant, S; Haubois, X; Heissel, G; Henning, T; Hinkley, S; Hippler, S; Houlle, M; Hubert, Z; Jocou, L; Keppler, M; Kervella, P; Kurtovic, NT; Lagrange, AM; Lapeyrere, V; Le Bouquin, JB; Lutz, D; Maire, AL; Mang, F; Marleau, GD; Merand, A; Monnier, JD; Mordasini, C; Ott, T; Otten, GPPL; Paladini, C; Paumard, T; Perraut, K; Perrin, G; Pfuhl, O; Pourre, N; Pueyo, L; Ribeiro, DC; Rickman, E; Ruffio, JB; Rustamkulov, Z; Shimizu, T; Sing, D; Stadler, J; Straub, O; Straubmeier, C; Sturm, E; Tacconi, LJ; van Dishoeck, EF; Vigan, A; Vincent, F; von Fellenberg, SD; Widmann, F; Winterhalder, TO; Woillez, J; Yazici, S;

Publication
ASTRONOMY & ASTROPHYSICS

Abstract
With four companions at separations from 16 to 71 au, HR 8799 is a unique target for direct imaging, presenting an opportunity for a comparative study of exoplanets with a shared formation history. Combining new VLTI/GRAVITY observations obtained within the ExoGRAVITY program with archival data, we performed a systematic atmospheric characterisation across all four planets. We explored different levels of model flexibility to understand the temperature structure, chemistry, and clouds of each planet using both petitRADTRANS atmospheric retrievals and fits to self-consistent radiative-convective equilibrium models. Using Bayesian model averaging to combine multiple retrievals (a total of 89 across all four planets), we find that the HR 8799 planets are highly enriched in metals, with [M/H] greater than or similar to 1, and have stellar to superstellar atmospheric C/O ratios. The C/O ratio increases with increasing separation from 0.55(-0.10)(+0.12) for d to 0.78(-0.04)(+0.03) for b, with the exception of the innermost planet, which has a C/O ratio of 0.87 +/- 0.03. Such high metallicities are unexpected for these massive planets, and challenge planet-formation models. By retrieving a quench pressure and using a disequilibrium chemistry model, we derive vertical mixing strengths compatible with predictions for high-metallicity, self-luminous atmospheres. Bayesian evidence comparisons strongly favour the presence of HCN in HR 8799 c and e, as well as CH4 in HR 8799 c, with detections at > 5 sigma confidence. All of the planets are cloudy, with no evidence of patchiness. The clouds of c, d, and e are best fit by silicate clouds lying above a deep iron cloud layer, while the clouds of the cooler HR 8799 b are more likely composed of Na2S. With well-defined atmospheric properties, future exploration of this system is well positioned to unveil further details of these planets, extending our understanding of the composition, structure, and formation history of these siblings.

2024

Astrometric detection of a Neptune-mass candidate planet in the nearest M-dwarf binary system GJ65 with VLTI/GRAVITY

Authors
Abuter, R; Amorim, A; Benisty, M; Berger, JP; Bonnet, H; Bourdarot, G; Bourget, P; Brandner, W; Clénet, Y; Davies, R; Delplancke-Ströbele, F; Dembet, R; Drescher, A; Eckart, A; Eisenhauer, F; Feuchtgruber, H; Finger, G; Schreiber, NMF; Garcia, P; Garcia-Lopez, R; Gao, F; Gendron, E; Genzel, R; Gillessen, S; Hartl, M; Haubois, X; Haussmann, F; Henning, T; Hippler, S; Horrobin, M; Jochum, L; Jocou, L; Kaufer, A; Kervella, P; Lacour, S; Lapeyrère,; Le Bouquin, JB; Ledoux, C; Léna, P; Lutz, D; Mang, F; Mérand, A; More, N; Nowak, M; Ott, T; Paumard, T; Perraut, K; Perrin, G; Pfuhl, O; Rabien, S; Ribeiro, DC; Bordoni, MS; Shangguan, J; Shimizu, T; Stadler, J; Straub, O; Straubmeier, C; Sturm, E; Tacconi, LJ; Tristram, KRW; Vincent, F; von Fellenberg, S; Widmann, F; Wieprecht, E; Woillez, J; Yazici, S; Zins, G;

Publication
ASTRONOMY & ASTROPHYSICS

Abstract
The detection of low-mass planets orbiting the nearest stars is a central stake of exoplanetary science, as they can be directly characterized much more easily than their distant counterparts. Here, we present the results of our long-term astrometric observations of the nearest binary M-dwarf Gliese 65 AB (GJ65), located at a distance of only 2.67 pc. We monitored the relative astrometry of the two components from 2016 to 2023 with the VLTI/GRAVITY interferometric instrument. We derived highly accurate orbital parameters for the stellar system, along with the dynamical masses of the two red dwarfs. The GRAVITY measurements exhibit a mean accuracy per epoch of 50-60 ms in 1.5 h of observing time using the 1.8 m Auxiliary Telescopes. The residuals of the two-body orbital fit enable us to search for the presence of companions orbiting one of the two stars (S-type orbit) through the reflex motion they imprint on the differential A-B astrometry. We detected a Neptune-mass candidate companion with an orbital period of p = 156 +/- 1 d and a mass of mp = 36 +/- 7 M circle plus. The best-fit orbit is within the dynamical stability region of the stellar pair. It has a low eccentricity, e = 0.1 - 0.3, and the planetary orbit plane has a moderate-to-high inclination of i > 30 degrees with respect to the stellar pair, with further observations required to confirm these values. These observations demonstrate the capability of interferometric astrometry to reach microarcsecond accuracy in the narrow-angle regime for planet detection by reflex motion from the ground. This capability offers new perspectives and potential synergies with Gaia in the pursuit of low-mass exoplanets in the solar neighborhood.

2024

Using the motion of S2 to constrain vector clouds around Sgr A

Authors
Foschi, A; Abuter, R; Abd El Dayem, K; Aimar, N; Seoane, PA; Amorim, A; Berger, JP; Bonnet, H; Bourdarot, G; Brandner, W; Davies, R; de Zeeuw, PT; Defrére, D; Dexter, J; Drescher, A; Eckart, A; Eisenhauer, F; Schreiber, NMF; Garcia, PJ; Genzel, R; Gillessen, S; Gomes, T; Haubois, X; Heissel, G; Henning, T; Jochum, L; Jocou, L; Kaufer, A; Kreidberg, L; Lacour, S; Lapeyrére,; Le Bouquin, JB; Léna, P; Lutz, D; Mang, F; Millour, F; Ott, T; Paumard, T; Perraut, K; Perrin, G; Pfuhl, O; Rabien, S; Ribeiro, DC; Bordoni, MS; Scheithauer, S; Shangguan, J; Shimizu, T; Stadler, J; Straubmeier, C; Sturm, E; Subroweit, M; Tacconi, LJ; Vincent, F; von Fellenberg, S; Woillez, J;

Publication
MONTHLY NOTICES OF THE ROYAL ASTRONOMICAL SOCIETY

Abstract
The dark compact object at the centre of the Milky Way is well established to be a supermassive black hole with mass M-center dot similar to 4.3 x 10(6) M-circle dot, but the nature of its environment is still under debate. In this work, we used astrometric and spectroscopic measurements of the motion of the star S2, one of the closest stars to the massive black hole, to determine an upper limit on an extended mass composed of a massive vector field around Sagittarius A*. For a vector with effective mass 10(-19) (less than or similar to) m(s less than or similar to) 10(-18) eV, our Markov chain Monte Carlo analysis shows no evidence for such a cloud, placing an upper bound M-cloud (less than or similar to) 0.1 % M-center dot at 3 sigma confidence level. We show that dynamical friction exerted by the medium on S2 motion plays no role in the analysis performed in this and previous works, and can be neglected thus.

2024

The size-luminosity relation of local active galactic nuclei from interferometric observations of the broad-line region

Authors
Amorim, A; Bourdarot, G; Brandner, W; Cao, Y; Clénet, Y; Davies, R; de Zeeuw, PT; Dexter, J; Drescher, A; Eckart, A; Eisenhauer, F; Fabricius, M; Feuchtgruber, H; Schreiber, NMF; Garcia, PJV; Genzel, R; Gillessen, S; Gratadour, D; Hönig, S; Kishimoto, M; Lacour, S; Lutz, D; Millour, F; Netzer, H; Ott, T; Paumard, T; Perraut, K; Perrin, G; Peterson, BM; Petrucci, PO; Pfuhl, O; Prieto, MA; Rabien, S; Rouan, D; Santos, DJD; Shangguan, J; Shimizu, T; Sternberg, A; Straubmeier, C; Sturm, E; Tacconi, LJ; Tristram, KRW; Widmann, F; Woillez, J;

Publication
ASTRONOMY & ASTROPHYSICS

Abstract
By using the GRAVITY instrument with the near-infrared (NIR) Very Large Telescope Interferometer (VLTI), the structure of the broad (emission-)line region (BLR) in active galactic nuclei (AGNs) can be spatially resolved, allowing the central black hole (BH) mass to be determined. This work reports new NIR VLTI/GRAVITY interferometric spectra for four type 1 AGNs (Mrk 509, PDS 456, Mrk 1239, and IC 4329A) with resolved broad-line emission. Dynamical modelling of interferometric data constrains the BLR radius and central BH mass measurements for our targets and reveals outflow-dominated BLRs for Mrk 509 and PDS 456. We present an updated radius-luminosity (R-L) relation independent of that derived with reverberation mapping (RM) measurements using all the GRAVITY-observed AGNs. We find our R-L relation to be largely consistent with that derived from RM measurements except at high luminosity, where BLR radii seem to be smaller than predicted. This is consistent with RM-based claims that high Eddington ratio AGNs show consistently smaller BLR sizes. The BH masses of our targets are also consistent with the standard MBH-sigma* relation. Model-independent photocentre fitting shows spatial offsets between the hot dust continuum and the BLR photocentres (ranging from similar to 17 mu as to 140 mu as) that are generally perpendicular to the alignment of the red- and blueshifted BLR photocentres. These offsets are found to be related to the AGN luminosity and could be caused by asymmetric K-band emission of the hot dust, shifting the dust photocentre. We discuss various possible scenarios that can explain this phenomenon.

2024

VLTI/GRAVITY Provides Evidence the Young, Substellar Companion HD136164Ab Formed Like a Failed Star

Authors
Balmer, WO; Pueyo, L; Lacour, S; Wang, JJ; Stolker, T; Kammerer, J; Pourré, N; Nowak, M; Rickman, E; Blunt, S; Sivaramakrishnan, A; Sing, D; Wagner, K; Marleau, GD; Lagrange, AM; Abuter, R; Amorim, A; Asensio-Torres, R; Berger, JP; Beust, H; Boccaletti, A; Bohn, A; Bonnefoy, M; Bonnet, H; Bordoni, MS; Bourdarot, G; Brandner, W; Cantalloube, F; Caselli, P; Charnay, B; Chauvin, G; Chavez, A; Choquet, E; Christiaens,; Clénet, Y; du Foresto, VC; Cridland, A; Davies, R; Dembet, R; Drescher, A; Duvert, G; Eckart, A; Eisenhauer, F; Schreiber, NMF; Garcia, P; Lopez, RG; Gendron, E; Genzel, R; Gillessen, S; Girard, JH; Grant, S; Haubois, X; Heissel, G; Henning, T; Hinkley, S; Hippler, S; Houllé, M; Hubert, Z; Jocou, L; Keppler, M; Kervella, P; Kreidberg, L; Kurtovic, NT; Lapeyrère,; Le Bouquin, JB; Léna, P; Lutz, D; Maire, AL; Mang, F; Mérand, A; Mollière, P; Mordasini, C; Mouillet, D; Nasedkin, E; Ott, T; Otten, GPPL; Paladini, C; Paumard, T; Perraut, K; Perrin, G; Pfuhl, O; Ribeiro, DC; Rodet, L; Rustamkulov, Z; Shangguan, J; Shimizu, T; Straubmeier, C; Sturm, E; Tacconi, LJ; Vigan, A; Vincent, F; Ward-Duong, K; Widmann, F; Winterhalder, T; Woillez, J; Yazici, S;

Publication
ASTRONOMICAL JOURNAL

Abstract
Young, low-mass brown dwarfs orbiting early-type stars, with low mass ratios (q less than or similar to 0.01), appear to be intrinsically rare and present a formation dilemma: could a handful of these objects be the highest-mass outcomes of planetary formation channels (bottom up within a protoplanetary disk), or are they more representative of the lowest-mass failed binaries (formed via disk fragmentation or core fragmentation)? Additionally, their orbits can yield model-independent dynamical masses, and when paired with wide wavelength coverage and accurate system age estimates, can constrain evolutionary models in a regime where the models have a wide dispersion depending on the initial conditions. We present new interferometric observations of the 16 Myr substellar companion HD 136164 Ab (HIP 75056 Ab) made with the Very Large Telescope Interferometer (VLTI)/GRAVITY and an updated orbit fit including proper motion measurements from the Hipparcos-Gaia Catalog of Accelerations. We estimate a dynamical mass of 35 +/- 10 M-J (q similar to 0.02), making HD 136164 Ab the youngest substellar companion with a dynamical mass estimate. The new mass and newly constrained orbital eccentricity (e = 0.44 +/- 0.03) and separation (22.5 +/- 1 au) could indicate that the companion formed via the low-mass tail of the initial mass function. Our atmospheric fit to a SPHINX M-dwarf model grid suggests a subsolar C/O ratio of 0.45 and 3 x solar metallicity, which could indicate formation in a circumstellar disk via disk fragmentation. Either way, the revised mass estimate likely excludes bottom-up formation via core accretion in a circumstellar disk. HD 136164 Ab joins a select group of young substellar objects with dynamical mass estimates; epoch astrometry from future Gaia data releases will constrain the dynamical mass of this crucial object further.

  • 37
  • 369